Home > Legal Discussion Forums > Labour / Employee Related Laws

Gratuity Payable or not

pramod Full Member - Member Since: Oct 2008
Subject - Gratuity Payable or not
Dear all
one person has worked in an Organisation for 4 yrs and nearly 9-10 month and resigned from the service. now he is claiming for gratuity stating " since i worked 4 yrs and 240 days continuous service in 5th yrs kindly settle my gratuity amount"

in view of above whether he is entile for gratuity as per gratuity act 5 yrs service is required.

regards

Pramod
malikjs Full Member - Member Since: Oct 2008
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
dear pramod
he is not entitle for gratuity because minimum five years of service is required to become eligible for gratuity.in one case madras high court has given judgement that if someone has completed 240 days in fifth year than he becomes eligible for gratuity,but it can not become a rule as there is no amendment in act.act will prevail the judgement.
tks
j s malik
pramod Full Member - Member Since: Oct 2008
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
Dear Mallik Sir
now what will be solution?
employee is clearly mentioned that he has worked 4 yrs and 240 days in co..
pl. give gratutiy.

what shall be reply to employee?

early reply pl.

pramod
malikjs Full Member - Member Since: Oct 2008
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
dear
you can write a letter to him that as per act you are not entitle for the same as you have not completed five years of service.
tks
j s malik
irudayamarockiam Full Member - Member Since: Feb 2009
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
Dear Mr.Promod,
1. Under sec.4 (1), Gratuity shall be payable to an employee on the termination of his employment after he has rendered "continuous service" for not less than five years,--

2.As Regards, the question of the 5th year of service, though the said employee had not completed one calendar year i.e. 12 months, where there is non-completion of 12 calender year, we have to rely upon( Sec. 2A (2) where an employee (not being an employee employed in a seasonal establishment) is not in continuous service within the meaning of clause (1), for any period of one year or six months, he shall be deemed to be in continuous service under the employer--

(a) for the said period of one year, if the employee during the period of twelve calendar months preceding the date with reference to which calculation is to be made, has actually worked under the employer for not less than--

(i) one hundred and ninety days, in the case of an employee employed below the ground in a mine or in an establishment which works for less than six days in a week; and

(ii) two hundred and forty days, in any other case;

The employee by virtue of having served 240 days in the 5th qualifying year therefore deemded to have completed 5 years of continuous ervice and hence Gratuity is payable.
A.Irudayam
Advocate and HR consultant
+9199406 86632
pramod Full Member - Member Since: Oct 2008
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
Mr. Irudayam & Mr. Mallik Sir
Now can we pay gratuity to all employee who had left the services after -
completing 4 yrs and 240 days in 5th yr(8month )continuous service.

may pl. reply becoz today we have to take final decision.
reply sharp

pramod
irudayamarockiam Full Member - Member Since: Feb 2009
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
Dear Mr.Prmod,
240 days in 8 months during the fifth year is as aggod as impossible. It means that the person was on continuous duty. Don't rush payment now.I am cross checking with more citations.
A.Irudayam
malikjs Full Member - Member Since: Oct 2008
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
dear pramod
i donot feel that we should pay gratuity to an employee who has completed 240 days in fifth year.i too agree with friend mr irudayam who made the intrpretation on this basis only madras high court has given judgement.but there is no change in applicablity clause of the said act ,so on this basis only we can not pay gratuity.
even some companies have insured gratuity through LIC and LIC also does not pay if service is less than 5 years.
tks
j s malik
Godse Sopan Karbhari - Member Since: Oct 2008
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
Gratuity is payable in case of 4 yrs and 240 days completed.(to make it five years) I do not have any citation to support.
Regards,
K C S Kutty Full Member - Member Since: Nov 2008
Subject - Re: Gratuity Payable or not
Working 240 days in the fifth year is sufficient to be eligible for gratuity. There is no need to refer to any case laws as Section 2A inserted by Act 26 of 1984 ( w.e.f. 11.2.1981) is very clear in this regard.
Kindly go through Section 2A and Section 4(1).
Section 4 (1) says about completion of "continuous service" of 5 years and S 2A defines what is meant by continuous service. Section 4 nowhere mentions that an employee has to complete "five Calendar years".

KCS Kutty, Chennai


CiteLegal is a community knowledgebase that let's you put your legal issues in front
of a large group of law practitioners and if required find a lawyer through discussion.


Contact Us - Tags - CiteLegal Index - Top RSS

Privacy Policy | Disclaimer | Terms Of Service